I feel very lucky to be registered with an excellent General Practice. I have always received good and timely care. I have just had a total hip replacement and my recovery has gone very well. After 12 days, I attended my practice to have my staples removed. We often struggle to define personalised care; it is easier to say what it is not. What happened during my appointment left me feeling unhappy and like a failure. Yet a few simple things would have made the world of difference to me.

This was my first trip out since returning from hospital. I was naturally anxious about what this would feel like and if it would hurt. Getting in and out of the car required great care. I walked the short distance from the car park on my two crutches.

When I knocked and entered the consultation room the lady did not get up, greet me, or introduce herself. In fact, the first words she spoke to me was to tell me that ‘You shouldn’t still be on your crutches.’ I was taken aback. Was this true? No one had mentioned that when I was discharged, and the exercises I was doing at this stage were very modest – lying down or seated. I believed I was doing well, but in one comment, I felt like a failure and my confidence went through the floor.

‘We are removing stitches’, she said. Without getting up from her seat she locked the door and said ‘drop your trousers’. I was standing in the middle of the room, now feeling very vulnerable. She removed the dressing and said, ‘It bled a lot’. I was not sure what to do with that statement; was this bad? A problem? The dressing had been on since I was discharged and with no sign of blood, so had not been changed. I had no idea what was underneath.

She then proceeded to take out my staples. I did not realise that she would do it while I was standing. She explained that I would feel a sting as she took each one out. Which was an accurate description. It went smoothly and was over very quickly, which was a relief.

‘All done’.

That’s it? But I had lots of questions. She was the first clinician I had seen since I left hospital. Could I shower? When could I sit on a normal height chair….

The showering was OK, but she had no answers to my other questions and did not signpost me to where I could find out. It was all over. At some point before I left, she did acknowledge that I had had major surgery. That was too little, too late.

I was upset for the rest of the day. Until this point, I believed my recovery was going well, I was doing all my exercises and felt I was managing well. Instead of compassion, I felt told off. I felt like a task to be done ‘Staples out’, rather than a human being to be cared for and encouraged. At no point did I feel that she had seen me, or understood what was going on for me, or my personal journey through the unknown.

The sad thing is that it would have only taken a few seconds to show me compassion, put me at ease and ensure that I left with confidence to keep going on this very  journey of recovery:

‘Hello my name is….’ Introducing herself and helping to build rapport.

‘You have had major surgery….How are you doing?  Acknowledging my situation and helping me relax. Asking an open question, so that I felt listened to and heard. Showing compassion and humanity.

‘You’re here to have your staples removed. Let’s have a look at your wound. I am going to ask you to stay standing as this is the best position for you to be in…’ Reassuring me and explaining the procedure.

‘Do you have any questions?’ Showing compassion and empathy. Even if she had not known the answers, she could have signposted me to where to find them.

Footnote

Five days later, when I had recovered my sense of confidence, I sent some feedback to the practice about my experience. The next day, I received a phone call from the lead nurse, apologising for how it had made me feel, reassuring me that the member of staff had been given some feedback. She thanked me for my feedback, which would be shared more widely with the team to ensure that everyone is treated with humanity and all the staff could learn from this example. As I say, I feel very lucky to be at a good practice. It only takes a few words and behaviours to disempower and upset someone – or show compassion and build confidence and wellbeing. We all have a choice.

Compassion in healthcare is not just a feeling—it has a profound impact on patient outcomes, as explored by Dr Stephen Trzeciak, a physician scientist and intensivist. Dr Trzeciak is the Edward D. Viner Endowed Chief of Medicine at Cooper University Health Care and Professor and Chair of Medicine at Cooper Medical School of Rowan University. His research, supported by leading health organisations, highlights the measurable effects of compassion in medical practice. He is also the co-author of Compassionomics and Wonder Drug, books that explore the science behind kindness and its benefits for both patients and healthcare providers. In his TED Talk, Dr Trzeciak shares compelling insights into why compassion matters in medicine—watch it here: Stephen Trzeciak TED Talk.

Compassion also has direct cost benefits. In the UK, a study found that when a patient has an unmet need for a personal connection with their GP, they are 47% more likely to be referred to a specialist. And in the US, the American Medical Association estimates that the cost to the economy of staff turnover linked to physician burnout is $12 billion annually. These are powerful reminders that compassion isn’t a luxury in healthcare—it’s a necessity, both for the wellbeing of individuals and the sustainability of the system.