In March 2022, the much-awaited Ockenden report was published, the result of an independent review into maternity services at the Shrewsbury and Telford Hospital NHS Trust over an almost 20 year period. Whilst the report rightly emphasises the tremendous work undertaken by maternity staff in the NHS, especially in the context of an environment with not enough staff and the pandemic making working conditions highly stressful, there are many lessons that can be learnt as a result of what went wrong and in particular the need for more person-centred conversations in maternity.
The British Medical Journal (BMJ) highlights that the Ockenden report is the fourth such report in recent years (another being the Kirkup report in 2015, regarding maternity services in Morecambe Bay), where sadly, the findings are similar. There is a recurring theme of women and families continuing to feel ignored in relation to their care, and in the event of things going wrong, poor explanations of what and why it happened. In other words, there seems to be a significant issue with communication.
Prior to the final Ockenden report, an earlier interim report highlighted seven key recommendations/actions to improve maternity services. Of these, there are three we believe are the key to improving outcomes for all:
- Listening to women and families – Maternity services must ensure that women and their families are listened to with their voices heard
- Staff training and working together – Staff who work together must train together with multidisciplinary training
- Informed consent – Women must be enabled to participate equally in all decision making regarding their care
As providers of communications, coaching and leadership training to the NHS and wider health and care system in the UK over the past five years, we have considerable insights into how to make improvements in these three areas that will not only improve the outcomes for women and their babies, but also for maternity staff too.
The most important aspect of the training we provide is around how to have person-centred conversations. But what does this mean? Put simply, it means a health and care professional puts the patient at the centre of the conversation by making a small, yet significant change to the questions they ask. Instead of focusing on What is the matter with you?, they ask “What matters to you?”. This creates a different dynamic and gives the patient the space, permission and time to share what is currently going on with them right now, their values, what is important to them, how they are feeling, and how they want their care to be. By framing the conversation this way, you are inviting the patient to open up and share more with you as a health and care professional, which in turn will enable you to have a deeper understanding of their specific needs, understand how you can best help them and enable informed consent, so that you can both agree what care is most appropriate.
This idea of “What matters to you” is the key to delivering a step change in communication within health and care, that it even has its own annual day (9th June) celebrated by the NHS as part of its Long Term Plan. If you want to understand more about how this approach delivers greater levels of personalised care, there are some great resources provided by the NHS you can find here and here.
However, asking the right questions is only the start of achieving the Ockenden Report recommendations, as giving space for patients to respond and importantly, actively listening to what they say is also vital. It’s about truly hearing what people are saying and responding accordingly, rather than having your own fixed agenda and imposing it on others. In the maternity space, this means listening to women and how they want their birth to go, rather than imposing how a delivery will happen before the woman in labour has even arrived or been spoken to.
Too often during a conversation, people are thinking about what they want to say next, while the other person is speaking, rather than letting go of their own thoughts to truly listen and hear what they have to say. By truly listening, this empowers the patient to play a crucial part in their own care, which will enable much higher levels of personalised care, as well as building a greater level of rapport and trust between women and their maternity support team. This will ultimately lead to higher levels of care and better health outcomes, as care is tailored to the needs of the individual. Some maternity units already do this very well, but as we have seen in the case of Shrewsbury and other trusts before it, where active listening and person-centred communication does not take place, and instead an organisational, top-down, ‘we know best’ approach to care is taken, it can lead to terrible consequences.
The third recommendation highlighted that we believe is most important, is the need for staff who work together, to train together. This does not mean just focussing on training midwives, but instead insists on a multidisciplinary approach, including everyone who is potentially involved in the care of women during and after pregnancy, to train together. We could not agree more with this recommendation and have seen first-hand the significant benefits of training people together with different areas of experience and specialisms. This includes breaking down barriers between different groups, eroding ingrained hierarchies and respecting each other. This brings a greater appreciation of what each other brings to the care of a patient, awareness of issues outside their immediate area, that builds a genuine sense of teamwork, with everyone working towards the same goal: the best possible health outcome for a patient.
We understand that hindsight is a wonderful thing and that it is much easier looking back over a situation from the calm of a review board, instead of in the moment when health and care professionals are under immense pressure. Nevertheless, by learning and embracing the principles of person-centred conversations, actively listening and training as a team towards a shared goal, everyone can make a significant difference to not only patients, but health and care professionals too.
If you would like any support or training in how to have more effective communication amongst your teams, please get in touch or find out more information here.
